I am not sure whether or not I agree with Marc Prensky or not. I do not think it is fair to any student to put the pressure on them to make sure every other student can pass a test. I believe a teachers job is to help nurture a well rounded student. Marc's idea would only work for those students to enjoy technology and have an i-pod or cell phone. I know if I were one of those students I would be LESS motivated to learn. I don't need a 3D printer have never had the coordination to play a video game.
I do agree, however, that if students have the right motivation to learn, they will. It doesn't have to be as great as having Kimora Lee Simmons teaching them to design a handbag, what ever happened to earning a good grade as enough incentive?
In the end, I Do think the student would be able to accomplish his goal, I just don't think it's fair to teach (or not teach) them that way.
Friday, September 7, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
9 comments:
I agree with you; motivation is the salient issue in this article. Of course, the pressures caused by Prensky's slightly outrageous idea would not work with all students, especially those who do not find technology that enticing. I believe Prensky's idea has another motive. I think he is tring to say that more technology should be used in order to improve acquisition and application. What do you think?
I agree with you Liz, students should be accountable for their own education, not necessarily their peers. I'm not sure I agree with you in the area of students accomplishing his goal. It seems too ambitious to cover a whole years worth of information in just one short semester and still be held accountable to the same state testing standards.
I agree with you that the ideas behind this challenge really take educators out of the teaching equation and put too much responsiblity on the students. I also agree that not all students are motivated by technology. I'm with you - I could care less about video games but I would love to learn about fashion from Kimora Lee Simmons! Good teachers work with students as individuals in order to discover the best ways to motivate each unique member of a class.
I agree with you; that motivating students is the way to get them to learn and achieve great scores. I also think that students should not have to be responsible for teaching each other, that responsibility lies within the teacher. Using technology is a great idea, especially because it is used so much with everything we do, however, I think that areas such as the arts, fashion, athletics, etc. should also be used as motivators.
With more of a focus on distance learning and independent learning, for those students who could handle the responsibility of independent study, would Prensky's ideas be a suitable "carrot" to dangle?
Motivating students is very important. I agree with you on this point. I do disagree with the way that Prensky wants to motivate our children. Technology isn't for everyone. I am on your side with that one. Just about a month ago I got my first IPOD. Teachers are a special kind of person. You are right, one of our jobs is to nurture a well rounded student. I always wanted to be a teacher and a teacher teaches children, not watches childern teach other children every day.
I agree that not all students learn the same way. Technology may not appeal to many students and we as educators could not base an entire curriculum just on the importance of technology.
Kristin mentioned watching children teach other children is not what she likes to do. However if you look at most skills that kids have that they like to do, none of them were taught by teachers. They either learned it themselves or from their friends.
I agree with you Liz. Each student is motivated differently. To try to motivate all the students with same carrot would not work. In the classroom you can see that some students have an inherent motivation to learn, while others need other forces to encourage their learning.
Post a Comment