Wednesday, October 17, 2007

Results...Now?

It took me a while to get through this reading. I kept throwing it down because I was so upset with many of the points Schmoker tried to get across. I understand that the American education system is not up to par, but is that entirely the teachers fault? How can we perform 100% when we are only given 5%(if that) of what we need? Not to mention, only paid for 10%(if that) of what we do. I have come to realize that teaching is not a cooperative effort. It is only as good as the teacher in the classroom. According to Schmoker, the statistics speak for themselves. Teachers aren't teaching effectively and students aren't learning properly.

Teachers need support, and I turly think that is the key to effective teaching. Teachers need money and more time in the day. It needs to be mentioned that many effective teachers get that way and get results from students without support, money, or time.

I do agree with Schmoker on one position-the isolation of teachers. I work in a school that has 3 buildings, 4-5 floors per building, and over 200 staff members. I have 1 supervisor, 4 asst. principals, and 1 principal. I can go almost the entire day only seeing at most 10 others employees. My supervisor observed me 3 weeks ago, and because I'm tenured, she won't observe me again until next year. I have only ever seen 1 asst. principal make it all the way up to the 5th floor where I am. We are supposed to have 3 minute observations done at random--I'm still waiting. I truly believe Teachers need more people breathing down their necks. They need to really understand that they are accountable for the education of children-our future. I see ineffective teachers everyday. As a history teacher I have seen a few teachers use films to guide the curriculum...and i mean they never teach, the students watch video's about everything!!!! If each and every teacher was worried about who saw them teaching, maybe they would be a little more conscious of their daily lessons. It is too easy for us to have an "i really don't feel like teaching day" and not engage the students in an effective lesson. I support 3min observations, I wouldn't mind parents observing a class, I don't care who walks into my room at any point, because I work hard to ensure that for the 48minutes i have a class, they will actually learn something.

After finishing the reading, I realized he might not be as wrong as I had originally thought. But it's never nice to read that people employed in the same profession as you don't have the same standards.

2 comments:

materiaj1 said...

I totally agree with the money and time comment; if we had more of the aforementioned would there be more effective teaching?
My fellow colleagues let's not get upset, we know that Schmoker's comments are somewhat true!

Prof. Bachenheimer said...

He presents an opinion that causes us to look in the mirror and ask if the best practices (and simple practices) are being performed in our classes.

Would you expect less than 100% from your physician, lawyer, tailor, auto mechanic? Should teachers be held any less accountable?

Or, if teachers are giving 100%, is it the most effective 100%?